Sunday, November 4, 2012

Election 2012- We've Only Just Begun

The election is Tuesday. Most are going to be glad when it’s finally over. But it’s really not going to be over- no matter who wins. It’s only the beginning.


We have some serious issues to address in this country. We can continue to kick the can down the road like we’ve been doing but we’re running out of road. And the stakes just keep getting bigger. We’re sitting here like the proverbial frog in the slowly boiling pot. We feel things getting hot, but we are not able to ask for a helping hand to get us out. Our politics won’t allow it.

It’s very likely that deciding the Presidential election on Tuesday may be a drawn-out affair. It is going to be close and could result in a president who has won the electoral college not the popular vote. That is not necessarily unusual. George W. Bush, Harry Truman, Woodrow Wilson (both times), Grover Cleveland (both times), Rutherford Hayes, Thomas Jefferson, and others have experienced the same thing. But this one may be different. Boatloads of lawyers are standing at the ready to challenge any and all aspects of the results. It could pull the country further apart rather than pulling us together.

At this point, it looks like the House will continue to be controlled by the Republicans and the Senate controlled by the Democrats. This hasn’t worked out all that well over the past four years. The emotions, the events, and the politics have created the most partisan Congress we’ve ever experienced in this country.

While the political process becomes more polarized we look ahead to “fiscal cliff” and the suffocating costs of health care we still have to address. Addressing them the right way will require real teamwork and collaboration between the parties and their constituents to reach some consensus on how to move forward. That’s the way a democracy is supposed to work. If we decide to keep growing further apart, every American is going to feel the consequences in some way or another.

So, no matter who ultimately “wins” the presidency on Tuesday (or whenever it is finally decided) this is only the beginning for the rest of us. Just because the election is settled doesn’t mean we can all shut-off our minds and move on to other things. There is too much at stake. We have a role we need to play to continue to hold those we have elected accountable and setting a direction that is good for the country and not based solely on a single political ideology. Believe it or not, both sides have some good ideas to share. Neither one has a lock on being right. While the elections may set a direction, we (the citizens) can do a lot to set the tone and demand the results.

We have a choice- not only about who is leading our country but about how it is going to be led. Now more than ever we need to stay involved and stay engaged and remain an integral part of the political process. If we continue to let individual party-ideology reign as the key determinant of how we're going to work in America- we're all going to lose. The choice is ours.

Thursday, October 4, 2012

Romney Won The Debate- But Still Not Clear About Health Care

There’s no doubt about it- from a political scorecard point of view, Mitt Romney “won” the debate last night. He was clear in his remarks and came across as the executive you would expect him to be; a very solid performance. President Obama didn’t seem like he just wasn’t into it and would rather be somewhere else. He didn’t go on the attack like his more liberal followers expected. Chris Mathews and Ed Schultz (MSNBC) went into a tirade after the debate lamenting the fact that Obama missed an opportunity to put Romney away. Today, Rush Limbaugh and Shawn Hannity are declaring victory and triumph for the other side.


While the pundits may have expected more fireworks (particularly from Obama) I actually enjoyed the debate. I know I’m in the minority but I like it when a debate includes a factual discussion of the issues that are relevant to those watching it.

Jim Leher (the moderator) had his critics as well. Once again, I didn’t think he did that bad. I enjoyed the free flow of the discussion as opposed to the game-show atmosphere that was prevalent in some of the debates we watched during the Republican primary. Once again, in today’s world my view is certainly the minority. Our culture today seems to want the fireworks, the vitriol, and the entertainment as opposed to a no-nonsense factual debate of the issues to educate the general public.

While Romney performed well when addressing the topic areas (the debt, the economy, taxes) he still didn’t address the question of how he was proposing to fix health care. He talked about RomneyCare and premium support for Medicare but didn't address how it was all supposed to work. The facts he used to summarize his position were generally misleading, lacked context, and he didn’t provide the specifics needed for the average citizen to make an informed decision about the best approach to use to fix the crisis we’re in.

For me, it’s pretty simple: Addressing the unsustainable increasing costs of health care is one of the most critical issues facing our country today. If we fix health care, we can go a long way to addressing our debt. If we address our debt we can go further in growing the economy. If we grow the economy we can create jobs. And that’s the issue for many.

Obamacare (the Affordable Care Act) is too expensive and doesn’t go nearly as far as we need to go to change how health care delivery works in this country. Obamacare needs to be fixed but it’s a start. In my view, Mitt Romney and Paul Ryan still need to present a plan (not just talking points but an actual plan) that makes sense as an alternative to the Affordable Care Act- then, voters like me (who believe health care may very well create the next economic crisis in our country if something doesn’t change) can make a clear decision on which approach is best.

And that will determine the way we vote.

Tuesday, September 11, 2012

9-11; Eleven Years Later




Let us never forget

And always remember those who have sacrificed and continue to sacrifice to fight for our freedom.

Saturday, September 8, 2012

New IOM Report- Will We Listen This Time?

The Institute of Medicine was created in 1970 as a subgroup of the National Academies and Sciences. The Institute is an “advisor to the nation” on the relevant policy and social issues of health and of the challenges facing our health care system and. It includes a lot of smart people from all areas of the health care system.


The Institute has already produced hundreds of studies and papers on a number of health care-related topics. Two of the most notable:

In 1999 the Institute produced “To Err is Human: Building a Safer Health System.” The research highlighted the number of deaths that are the result of medical errors in our health system.

In 2001 it released “Crossing the Quality Chasm; A New Health System for the 21st Century.” This paper emphasized the need for health care to become more “patient centered” and encouraged an entire restructuring of the delivery system. It stated, “What is perhaps most disturbing is the absence of real progress toward restructuring the health care system to address both quality and cost concerns. . .”

It just release another; “Best Care at Lower Cost; The Path to a Continuously Learning Health Care In America.” This study builds on the message it has tried to communicate to the general public for the past 13 years- the health care system is still in need of a fundamental restructuring in how it works and consumers need to be a fundamental part of the new system.

“Best Care at Lower Cost” estimates $750 billion was wasted in our health care system in 2009. Keep in mind Obama and Romney (regardless of what they say) are recommending to reduce Medicare payments (mainly through payment reductions to health plans, hospitals, home health) by $716 billion over ten years.

Eliminating the waste identified in the IOM report could reduce annual health expenditures by $750 billion in a single year or 30% of what we’re spending today. Not bad.

When “To Err is Human” was released in 1999, and “Crossing the Quality Chasm” was released in 2001 the media jumped on the conclusions for a short time, just like it did with the release of this report. Then health care went back to being health care. Our costs continued grow at unsustainable rates, our quality measures haven’t improved much, and somewhere between 75,000 and 100,000 people die unnecessarily each year due to medical errors.

One of these days we’re going to need to start listening to those prophesizing the reality of what we’re facing. The answers are out there and the general public needs to have a better understanding of the alternatives. Health care can be fixed- but is going to require a lot of changes. And we are all going to need to be part of the solution.



Thursday, August 9, 2012

Cheesecake Factory Health Care

Atul Gawande is a doctor who likes to write. He has presented some interesting ideas over the years. Health Care may be listening but it certainly hasn’t openly embraced his concepts; at least not yet. His 2009 article in the New Yorker about the high cost of health care in McAllen, Texas is sometimes credited with starting the whole health care reform discussion. His book, The “Checklist Manifesto”, presented the idea of using checklists (similar to the checklists used by pilots) to simplify the decision-making process in making medical decisions. His most recent article in the New Yorker, “Big Med”, discusses the processes used by the Cheesecake Factory and other “volume-based” food preparers and how they might be used to improve both the efficiency and quality in health care.


Health Care takes a long time to accept change. In the New Yorker article, Gawande references a study that examined how long it took several major health care discoveries to reach even half of Americans. On average, it took more than fifteen years.

In 2009, Americans spent over $200 billion in medical tests that were not needed. At the end of life an individual may see anywhere from 15 to 80 different medical specialists. Medical errors and quality challenges add billions more to a system that is already too expansive. While good medicine might not be able to be reduced to a recipe- Health Care could certainly use more effective processes to eliminate the waste and improve the quality of care delivered to the patient.

The Cheesecake Factory model is relatively simple; study what the best people are doing, figure out how to standardize it, and then bring it to everyone to execute.

We may not be able to create a Health Care Cheesecake Factory overnight, however, the system needs to start to be much more open to doing things different than it has in the past. There are some other ideas out there that can work- but it can’t take Health Care another fifteen years to make the changes that are needed. The individual, the patient, doesn’t have that much time.

Saturday, July 14, 2012

Minnesota Health Care- A Model For Other States?

I had the opportunity to provide testimony to the Minnesota Health Care Reform Task Force last week. This group was convened to develop new ideas and solutions to improve the health care in the state. Minnesota has always been looked upon as one of the “innovators” in the country when it comes to health care. It is the home of the Mayo Clinic, Medtronic, United Health Group, HealthPartners, Red Brick Health, and many other business model and product innovations that have been used as examples for other states in developing a more effective health care system for themselves.

The Task Force was certainly handed a huge task and must now integrate the federal requirements of the Affordable Care Act into its work. Despite the health care system that has developed in Minnesota over the years, it is still too expensive, too confusing, and many times inefficient.
The Task Force was provided updates from several of the work groups: Access (defining the benefit structures and pricing models to increase the number of individuals “covered” under a private or public health care financing program). Workforce (making certain the health care workforce is prepared to meet the future demand of health care). Health Insurance Exchange (developing the tools to implement a health insurance exchange market in Minnesota).

The four hour meeting was filled with handouts and presentations from the different groups. It was obvious to most that what was being discussed was going to cost a lot of money. It was also fairly obvious of the continuing confusion regarding the “rules” that must be followed to meet the requirements of the Affordable Care Act. Health care is complex- but these discussions made it even more confusing. There was very little (if any) discussion about how the average individual was going to understand any of it.

My testimony tried to at least bring the consumer/individual back into the discussion. I hope they were listening.

As I said, Minnesota is viewed as an innovator when it comes to health care. But Minnesota also struggles with the same challenges as other states to get consumers and individuals engaged and involved. With the complexity we are continuing to create- it’s no wonder.

Until groups like these begin to accept the economic realities we are facing, develop approaches based on a set of quantifiable objectives not utopian dreams, simplify the entire process, and include the perspectives of the “average citizen” in all of their discussions and decisions, we will probably just end up with a nice set of recommendations we can’t afford, that cost a lot of time and money to put together, and that we’ll just put on the shelf. We may move forward a little- but not nearly as far as we need to. But at least we're doing something.






Monday, July 2, 2012

The Supreme Court Decision and GSK; Which Way Will We Go?

It was fun to watch the cable news channels trip over themselves as they initially incorrectly reported the outcome of the Supreme Court decision last week. In their quest to report first- they reported wrong. Such is the price we have to pay when we want the news instantaneously. We’re going to need to be even more cautious when we’re determining what to believe; especially when it comes to deciding what to believe about health care.


Since the decision was made- the pundits have been trying to figure out what it really means. For all practical purposes, the guts of the law were upheld. It’s just that what things are called, and how things will work are going to change pretty substantially.

Even with the decision finally made, the health care debate is going to continue. The country is still divided on it view of the law. But the intensity of the division has intensified. The rhetoric behind the discussion will get even uglier than before. Just like we should have learned as the cable channels first reported the decision, what is reported will not necessarily be the truth.

The fundamental question we will continue to grapple with is this: how much should the government organize the health care mess we have created this country versus how much can we really rely on the “free market” in its ability to fix it.

Today, pharmaceutical company GlaxoSmithKline (GSK) agreed to a $3 billion settlement essentially resulting from health care fraud. The company was selling pharmaceuticals to markets where the drugs were not intended, and for conditions that had not been tested. The general public was exposed to some very substantial risks. But the GSK sales folks, some physicians, and others made a lot of money in the process; just following the American Dream. The GSK annual report states the ultimate aim of GSK’s business strategy is “to deliver sustainable improved long-term value and returns to shareholders.” There is no mention of delivering quality products at an affordable price to their customers. These companies are big, and the focus is financial. In an article about the fraud for Forbes Mathew Harper writes, “Criminal fines for giant drug companies, no matter how big, are less a deterrent than a cost of doing business.”

The free market left on its own can be dangerous.

So, we are still left to decide between a bloated and expensive health care law generally administered by the federal government that few understand and many people still don’t like, and uncertainty as to whether it will work, and a free market approach that continuously struggles to put the patient, the individual, ahead of profits.

I’ve said all along the answer is somewhere in-between. We just don’t have the right leaders in place to put a middle-ground approach together. The debate will continue.