When the Affordable Care Act was created we had a heated
discussion about the provision that provided doctors with compensation for
discussing the end-of-life care for their patients. Those opposing the law (and
everything else about it) introduced “death panels” and “pushing grandma off
the cliff” into the discourse. The public fell for it, and the section was
eliminated from the law. We didn’t want to talk about it anymore.
Well, the Institute of Medicine has resurrected the
discussion with its release of the 500 page report “Dying in America.” In it,
the IOM attempts to highlight how our existing health care system is woefully
unprepared to address the influx of deaths we should expect with an aging
population and why it’s only going to add unnecessary costs to an already
bloated health care system.
Here’s some facts to think about:
·
In 2011 we spent over $550 billion on Medicare.
Of that amount, approximately 28% was spent during the last 6 months of life
and 32% was spent during the last two years of life.
·
A study of patient inpatient hospital costs
during the last two years of life found huge variations in costs between
hospitals. At Mayo Clinic the inpatient costs were $53,000 while UCLA spent
$93,000 and New York University spent $105,000. There was no difference in
quality of life or outcome (all patients ultimately died.)
·
According to research at Dartmouth, while most
patients would prefer to die at home, nearly 55% ended up dying in the
hospital.
·
While most Americans believe it is important to
talk to their families about their end-of-life preferences, only 30% have
written instructions (Advanced Directives) on what they are.
Bottom-line:
Health care costs are greatest at the end of our lives (which is no surprise).
While we know it is important to document our end-of-life preferences, very few
have actually followed-through and outlined what we want. While most would
prefer to die at home (or a setting other than a hospital), the majority of us
will end-up dying in the hospital- and the costs to Medicare or our families
will be dependent upon which hospital we go to.
Even though we may not want to talk about it- death is a
reality. Our health care system is not equipped to predict our preferences when
we are no longer able to communicate what they are. Health care will throw all
its resources to prolonging a life no matter what we would have wanted. This
only adds to the emotional and financial costs associated with the event.
Talking with family and executing an Advanced Directive is
part of the role the new health care consumer will need to play. It’s about
accountability and direction for ourselves and for our family members who will
be making difficult decisions on our behalf.
This isn’t “pushing grandma off the cliff.” This is making easier for those we care
about. We need to talk about it.