Wednesday, September 17, 2014

End of Life Care- A Consumer Issue We Need To Talk About

Americans don’t like to talk about death.

When the Affordable Care Act was created we had a heated discussion about the provision that provided doctors with compensation for discussing the end-of-life care for their patients. Those opposing the law (and everything else about it) introduced “death panels” and “pushing grandma off the cliff” into the discourse. The public fell for it, and the section was eliminated from the law. We didn’t want to talk about it anymore.

Well, the Institute of Medicine has resurrected the discussion with its release of the 500 page report “Dying in America.” In it, the IOM attempts to highlight how our existing health care system is woefully unprepared to address the influx of deaths we should expect with an aging population and why it’s only going to add unnecessary costs to an already bloated health care system.

Here’s some facts to think about:

·         In 2011 we spent over $550 billion on Medicare. Of that amount, approximately 28% was spent during the last 6 months of life and 32% was spent during the last two years of life.

·         A study of patient inpatient hospital costs during the last two years of life found huge variations in costs between hospitals. At Mayo Clinic the inpatient costs were $53,000 while UCLA spent $93,000 and New York University spent $105,000. There was no difference in quality of life or outcome (all patients ultimately died.)

·         According to research at Dartmouth, while most patients would prefer to die at home, nearly 55% ended up dying in the hospital.

·         While most Americans believe it is important to talk to their families about their end-of-life preferences, only 30% have written instructions (Advanced Directives) on what they are.

Bottom-line: Health care costs are greatest at the end of our lives (which is no surprise). While we know it is important to document our end-of-life preferences, very few have actually followed-through and outlined what we want. While most would prefer to die at home (or a setting other than a hospital), the majority of us will end-up dying in the hospital- and the costs to Medicare or our families will be dependent upon which hospital we go to.

Even though we may not want to talk about it- death is a reality. Our health care system is not equipped to predict our preferences when we are no longer able to communicate what they are. Health care will throw all its resources to prolonging a life no matter what we would have wanted. This only adds to the emotional and financial costs associated with the event.

Talking with family and executing an Advanced Directive is part of the role the new health care consumer will need to play. It’s about accountability and direction for ourselves and for our family members who will be making difficult decisions on our behalf.

This isn’t “pushing grandma off the cliff.”  This is making easier for those we care about. We need to talk about it.

 

Tuesday, April 15, 2014

Obamacare: Not the Time to Spike the Ball

There was a lot of news coming out of the Obama Administration last week related to the Affordable Care Act (ACA). The Administration could certainly use some positive news about it and they did their best to capitalize and strategically coordinate the messages to the public. Quite honestly, I’m not sure how much was real news and how much was just an attempt to re-position their overall strategy with the general public. They have a lot of work to do.

First, was the announcement that over 7.5 million individuals used the different health insurance exchanges to purchase health insurance for themselves or their families.  This number miraculously exceeded the moving
target established to define the success of the implementation.  After the disastrous launch and rollout in October last year, this is certainly some positive news. Despite many questioning what the numbers actually mean, the Administration used the opportunity to spike the ball a few times while announcing it.

Second was the announcement that Kathleen Sebelius was going to leave her post as Cabinet Secretary at the Department of Health of Human Services. This wasn’t any surprise to most as she had stayed on much longer than many expected and as an added benefit she could now be used as the fall-guy/gal to blame future Obamacare problems and missteps.

As an added benefit, the Congressional Budget Office (CBO) and Joint Committee on Taxation (JCT) updated their numbers regarding the potential impact the ACA is having (will have) on the number of uninsured and the deficit. Despite all the changes in the law and the economy since it was enacted in 2010, the CBO/JCT estimate over 12 million individuals are financially protected with health insurance today that wouldn’t have been otherwise. By 2017 that number will rise to over 26 million. Additionally, while they can’t specifically quantify the number, they still believe the ACA will continue to have a positive impact on the deficit over the next 10 years.

I’m still not as sold on the Obamacare idea as I once was and you can certainly debate the meaning of some of the numbers being thrown around.  But, it’s the only defined strategy we have to work with right now. Until we have another real option (and just repealing the law with no replacement is not a real option) we’re going to need to fix what needs to be fixed and move on while we sort through the meaning of the numbers to see what they are telling us.

In the meantime, the Obama Administration should probably hold off from spiking the ball in victory any time soon. We still don’t know if this thing is going to work.

Tuesday, February 4, 2014

The Mandate for Contraception- Going Too Far and It Must Be Fixed

One of the things I liked about the Affordable Care Act when it was first introduced was that it tried to put more of an emphasis on prevention in the health care system. We all know our current system has evolved into a “sickness system” trying to fix an illness only after it develops. If we could begin to focus more of our time taking care of ourselves and preventing illness and disease before it happened, the costs would surely decline. It made sense.

And, it also made sense to put a special emphasis on “women’s health” as women tend to suffer disproportionately from chronic disease and for certain conditions adding to the overall cost of health care for everyone.

But there are limits as to how far the law should go.

In 2011, the Institutes of Medicine provided recommendations to the Department of Health and Human
Services of the types of services they believed could improve the health and wellness of women in the population through prevention and ultimately lower the costs over the longer-term. Their recommendations included:

1.       Improved screening for cervical cancer, counseling for sexually transmitted infections, and counseling and screening for HIV

2.       A fuller range of contraceptive education, counseling, methods, and services so that women can better avoid unwanted pregnancies and space their pregnancies to promote optimal birth outcomes

3.       Services for pregnant women including screening for gestational diabetes and lactation counseling and equipment to help women who choose to breastfeed do so successfully

4.       At least one well-woman preventive care visit annually for women to receive comprehensive services

5.       Screening and counseling for all women and adolescent girls for interpersonal and domestic violence in a culturally sensitive and supportive manner

In most cases, the recommendations made sense from a strictly economic/cost perspective. But they must be balanced with the rights established by our Constitution.

Only two weeks after the IOM made their recommendations (remarkably fast for any government decision or anything related to the Affordable Care Act) the Department of Health and Human Services accepted all recommendations and required the recommendations to be included in all health plans beginning in 2012 as part of the Affordable Care Act implementation- no exceptions.

Recommendation #2 (related to contraception) moved the discussion away from addressing the cost of health care- to a debate between a woman’s right to choose for some and the right for religious freedom for others. The issue will be settled legally by the United States Supreme Court later this year.

In a Senate debate a few weeks ago, Senator Patty Murray (D-Washington) stated, “What’s at stake in this case before the Supreme Court is whether a CEO’s personal beliefs can trump a woman’s right to access free or low-cost contraception under the Affordable Care Act.”

This is not a right to choose issue- but it remains a health care cost issue ad most certainly a religious freedom issue.

Since the personal beliefs in all of the challenged cases are, in-fact, based on the fundamental religious beliefs of those challenging this requirement, the answer to Senator Murray’s question should be a no-brainer, even to her. If the implementation of this law begins to infringe on the religious freedom and rights of the individuals it has gone too far and it’s time to put it in check.

And we have reached that point- at least for this part of it.


Thursday, January 9, 2014

Reforming Health Care is a Supply-Side Problem

Anyone who read the Affordable Care Act (ACA) when it was first enacted, has a basic understanding of how health care works, and comprehends the reality of the political world we live in isn’t surprised with how the implementation of the law has turned out so far. Unfortunately there aren’t many who possess all three traits.

From the beginning, the law was too big, too overreaching, tried to accommodate too many special interests and placed implementation responsibility in the control of a government not capable of its execution. The law has tried to create a universal health care environment with private market incentives in a private market that has little interest in creating a universal health care system in the first place. The pieces were just not going to fit together.

To be fair, the ACA has accomplished some good things by getting rid of some of the insurance underwriting practices that prevented the sick from having a means to pay for health care expenses and provides access
to health insurance to those who have not been able to afford it in the past. However, when you compare it to the number of people in the individual market who have been negatively impacted by this implementation you have to wonder if there might have been a better way to achieve better results. Unfortunately, things are not likely to get much better in the year ahead when employers are thrown into the mix.

The ACA is going to end up costing much more than originally anticipated and it still doesn’t even address the primary issue facing the country- increasing health care costs. The only way we’re going to address the cost problem is by creating a real health care system in this country that focuses on efficiency, collaboration, outcomes, and prevention. Reforming health care is a supply-side problem and the ACA focuses primarily on the demand.

There are alternatives to the ACA being discussed. These ideas (the main ones being the Empowering Patients First Act and the American Health Care Reform Act- you can find them by clicking here) also focus on the demand-side of the equation and will require market changes that aren’t going to be any easier to implement than the ACA. But they still don’t address the cost and inefficiency issue we are facing.

Numerous studies have indicated that anywhere from twenty-percent to over half of what we spend on health care is wasted in the delivery system we have today. We see it every day (the wasted money on web sites for the ACA is just another example.) By improving the way doctors, hospitals, and patients work together, changing payment and incentives, improving technology and communication, and eliminating the ungodly waste that exists we could easily pay for access to health insurance for those who need it while addressing the fundamental cost issue we face today.


While our politics and general public continue to focus on the availability of health insurance (demand) we’re continuing to focus on the wrong side of the equation. We need supply-side reform to make it work. 

Tuesday, November 19, 2013

Reducing Provider Networks- Not All the Fault of Obamacare

With all the distractions concerning the appalling Obamacare marketplace roll-out taking center-stage it would be wise for the country to try to keep in mind the bigger picture. It would be wise to remember that the economic/business model of our current health care system is simply unsustainable for the future. This current model spends more, wastes more, and takes up a larger percentage of our economic output than any other country in the world. The model simply has to change or it is going to collapse under its own weight.

Obamacare can (and should) be justifiably criticized for many deficiencies. However, we also need to keep in mind there are many other culprits that have put us in the position we’re in today. Obamacare is not the only cause. There is enough blame to go around for everyone.
United Healthcare recently announced it would be cutting loose between 10 and 20% of its Medicare Advantage provider network across the country. As is the normal plan of action in health care today, there was little communication or dialogue between stakeholders and the action has already resulted in lawsuits, further mistrust, and confusion for seniors as to whether their doctor was going to be part of the Medicare Advantage network in 2014 (especially during the Medicare open enrollment currently underway). The timing sucked for the consumers but it was easy to place the blame on Obamacare with all the other media hype going on today. A spokesman for United Healthcare stated (from the Wall Street Journal),” It’s no secret we are under substantial funding pressure from the federal government.” The message? Blame Obamacare.

Yes, Obamacare did cut funding for the Medicare Advantage plans to the health plans providing them. Numerous studies point to the fact that these became a profit center for health insurance plans and cost 10-15% more than traditional Medicare- and these costs are being funded by the taxpayers. The reduced funding was justified to address the costs of the program.

And yes, in order to address the cost of health care health plans will need to focus on the significant cost differences existing between physicians and hospitals across the country. Remember the Atul Gawande article that showed some areas of the country spend twice the Medicare dollars on health care for no particular reason. Some doctors cost more depending on where they live (see the Dartmouth Atlas if you want proof)

So, while United Healthcare is justified in creating a more cost-effective and efficient provider network they are not justified in blaming Obamacare for the reason. Reducing the provider network is something that could have been done many months ago to avoid putting consumers in the middle. Obamacare simply provided good cover.

Consumers need to be prepared. This won't be the last health insurance organization to make some significant changes to their network. This isn't just about Obamacare- this how a primarily for-profit insurance system is going to react when they finally have to focus on reducing costs. And, that's the ultimate goal.

Tuesday, October 29, 2013

Obamacare- The Next Hurdle? The Shortage of Doctors

It’s interesting. The country has been debating the pros and cons of the Affordable Care Act since it began in 2010. Unfortunately, until the discussion became relevant to the broader population the general public had remained largely detached.  Yes, some good things have come out of the law to help some of those with pre-existing conditions and to help the system finally start to work on prevention. But many questions about how all the pieces are going to fit together remain.

The debate about health care has been primarily political instead of looking out for what is good for the country and its citizens. Neither side has been willing to try to fix the cumbersome, complex, and expensive law that was enacted. It’s been all or nothing for both and we’re now living with the consequences.
I’ve been following the ACA since the beginning and I’m not all that surprised with the failure of the www.Healthcare.gov web site to work. The processes we are using to manage our government systems are dysfunctional- and the website rollout is a product of that dysfunction.

The country is now focused on www.Healthcare.gov because of the poor implementation and execution of a fundamental feature of the legislation. This rollout was very visible to most, and health care suddenly became more relevant to many.
But, www.Healthcare.gov is only the beginning. Once the site is fixed and running, more individuals will be participating in the broader health care system than before. The website is simply the pipeline for access into the delivery system.

What then?
The most likely answer lies in Massachusetts. After a similarly difficult rollout in the beginning, over 96% of all Massachusetts residents now have health insurance.  But they are facing other problems.

The Massachusetts Medical Society released two reports (2013MMS Patient Access to Care Study; and 2013 Workforce Study) that are likely indicative of what will happen nationally once more individuals enter the health care market.
In 2013, wait times in Massachusetts to schedule appointments with providers ranged from 22 days to 50 days for more routine services. Only 45% of internal medicine practitioners and 51% of family medicine practitioners are now accepting new patients. And a quote from one study states, “With no intervention, health care spending in Massachusetts will double by 2020.”

Even before the ACA was implemented, the country was projected to experience a significant shortage of primary care physicians by 2020. With more people entering the system, that shortage may occur much sooner. Obamacare will certainly be blamed- some of it justified for not addressing the problem before adding to it, some of it not because the problem existed anyway.
Consumers need to be prepared to wait longer and may have to spend more time finding a physician. In some cases (and regardless of the sales pitch) you may not be able to keep your doctor due to the realities of the market. It’s a simple matter of supply and demand.

Be prepared. And don’t be surprised or shocked when it happens. The politics of Obamacare is one thing, the reality is another.

Monday, October 21, 2013

Obamacare- Neither Side Has The Right Answer

In June, 2013 the Government Accountability Office presented a report regarding the overall status of the federally facilitated health insurance exchanges. This report covered the overall project status for the 34 states that were going to rely exclusively or partially on the federal government (CMS) to establish and maintain their health insurance marketplaces. The GAO was somewhat concerned back then. The report stated, “. . . and the many activities yet to be performed- some close to the start of enrollment, suggest a potential for challenges going forward.” We’re certainly going to have challenges going forward and nobody should really be surprised what has happened.

For the past 3 years we have heard the Republicans vowing to repeal the Affordable Care Act (Obamacare) with no vision or plan for replacement. Today, we heard President Obama and those on the left communicating that with the exception of the federal exchange (Healthcare.gov) everything is great in Obamacareland. Neither side is facing reality.
I was actually a supporter of the Affordable Care Act when it was passed in 2010. Finally, the country was going to do something to address the unsustainable health care costs in our country. Finally, the country was going to do something to help prevent individuals from losing everything because of the devastation created by a health care event. Finally, the country created a path to do something that would begin to get rid of the waste and inefficiency that everyone knows exists in the health care system today. I didn’t agree with the approach (getting everyone into an already broken system and then fix the system later) but at least the potential existed to make the changes that needed to be made. I was willing to give it some time.
Yes, the Affordable Care Act is the “law of the land,” yes, the ACA has survived Constitutional scrutiny from the Supreme Court, and yes, Romney wasn’t able to produce an alternative approach during the election last year. But it’s difficult to support an idea that has been communicated and implemented so poorly, fails to acknowledge its deficiencies, and doesn’t sound like its open to new ideas to help improve how it works for Americans.

Obama finally held a press conference that (I thought) was going to acknowledge the existing flaws, address the real misperceptions existing with and about the ACA, and the steps that were going to be taken to get it back on track. I thought he would certainly recognize the deficiencies existing with the federal Healthcare.gov web site, the challenges some employers are facing to implement the law, the disagreements many have with some of the requirements of the law, the reasons some individuals are experiencing “sticker shock” attributed to some of the features of the law, and the general confusion surrounding the intent of the law itself.  I thought he would finally be selling the broader purpose- the need to reform our health care delivery system for the good of the country and our economy- as opposed to simply selling health insurance.  He opted to just sell health insurance and trash the opposition.
The president was right when he stated the Affordable Care Act is more than just a web site. Some of the early features of the law have already helped many individuals (uninsured and those with pre-existing medical conditions). However, to get the general public engaged is going to require a providing a broader understanding of the steps that are needed to fix the mess that exists in our health care system today. It’s time we faced reality and acknowledge some things need to be fixed in the ACA and it should require collaboration and ideas from all sides. Health care reform should be about working together with all stakeholders to achieve a common goal for the country.  In 2010, I naively thought there would be some collaboration to fix what needed to be fixed in the ACA. That is obviously not where this is heading.

Reforming health care is not just trying to get people to go to a web site that does not work to buy health insurance. Unfortunately, that’s the message President Obama sent today and the flaws of the ACA are going to remain. The country will end-up paying for it.

Monday, September 9, 2013

Unfortunately, Misinformation Rules

Let me say from the start (and most of you who have been following this blog already know) I’m not a big fan of the Affordable Care Act/Obamacare. It’s too big for what we need right now, too expensive for where we are, and doesn’t address many of the fundamental flaws we have with the health care system in this country.

But, you should also know I am a huge fan of reforming the health care system - we all know it needs to
happen. Like it or not, the ACA is the option we have to work with right now- at least the only one that is not simply rhetoric or political talking points.

In my Health Care Politics and Policy class each quarter I challenge my students to interview 5 people to determine what they know about health care and health care reform as a learning project. Without exception, they return to the class absolutely amazed with how little most people know- but have strong opinions anyway. For most of us who have been following health care reform over the years, this is no surprise. The reality is most people have no clue of how health care works or what the Affordable Care Act is all about. But they are very quick to take a firm stance even when they know nothing about it.

From the beginning, the supporters of the ACA have done a terrible job educating the public about what health care reform is all about and why it is necessary. They have been afraid to talk about it because, quite simply, many don’t understand it themselves.

At the same time, those opposing the ACA (even though they have no suggestions or plans of their own) are spreading some pretty unbelievable stories and misinformation. And it’s only getting worse as time goes on.
Here are some of the good ones:
  • The ACA provides free health care to illegal aliens
  • The ACA will allow the government to decide when to stop providing medical care to the elderly
  • The ACA requires everyone to be implanted with microchips
  • The ACA will allow forced home inspections by government agents

 It is estimated that over $400 million is being spent to discredit the ACA and more money and energy is being poured into trying to get it repealed. The Americans for Prosperity launched a website for consumers www.obamacareriskfactors.com that stretches the limits of truth and fiction.

Individuals are growing increasingly confused by it all and believe the misinformation being circulated because their political views override their ability to critically think, research, and form an objective opinion of their own about the single most important social and economic issue facing our country.

From the beginning, the Affordable Care Act should have been looked at as a starting-point instead of a final solution. There are many things in the Act that can and should be fixed if we simply had the political ability to do so. The American public needs to be better informed to voice an educated opinion politicians need to listen to.  Until that happens, many will continue to believe the misinformation being spread by both sides and base their views on the political messages they are being fed instead of forming an opinion that makes sense for the country.

 In the meantime,  we’ll continue to fight between ourselves as we deal with an expensive, inefficient, and unfair health care system that will only continue to deplete the resources of the economic foundation of this country.


Obamacare is the target right now. If those fighting the law have a better idea- There are many who would like to hear it.

Thursday, August 22, 2013

Paul Bunyan and Babe Miss The Point

As predicted, the federal money being spent to market the health care exchanges is really flying out the door. Last Thursday the Department of Health and Human Services awarded another $60 million in grants to organization for the health care “navigators” who are supposed to help educate and enroll individuals in the exchanges.

The advertising campaigns for the exchanges in several states are also starting their kick-offs (remember, we’re supposed to be ready to go on October 1). The marketing theme for Connect for Health Colorado focuses on the benefits of the lower prices that are supposed to occur when health plans compete.  Oregonians are using folk music in their ads (Long Live Oregonians) to promote the CoverOregon exchange . And, only in Minnesota would we use Paul Bunyan to promote the MNSure health insurance exchange with the message “Land of 10,000 Reasons to Get Health Insurance” (not sure of the real message on this one).
Obamacare (or whatever you want to call it) has a serious branding problem. The Republicans still want to kill it and the Democrats don’t seem to want to fix it. Consumers are left in the middle not knowing what it really is and generally confused. These campaigns are going to need to break through a lot of political clutter.

Most of the statistics out there indicate that well over 70% of the population still doesn’t know what the health insurance exchange idea is all about. So, raising the awareness is an important first step. That’s what these advertising campaigns are supposed to do, and we’re spending a ton of money doing it.
Unfortunately, the real key to success of the whole Obamacare effort is to finally get individuals engaged in their health and the health care system- and being engaged is much more than just buying health insurance on an exchange. Engaged means being involved and aware of the bigger issue and aware of the reasons the health insurance exchange was created in the first place. It’s going to require some basic education about where we are in health care, what needs to happen to fix it, and what role each individual is being asked to play. We’re totally missing the boat on that one.

While the goal of these marketing campaigns is to raise the awareness and get as many people as possible to sign-up the real challenge is going to be what we do with them after they are in. The health care system is not being fixed, it will just have more people in it.

I don’t think Paul and Babe or the navigators will have very much to say about that.

Tuesday, July 9, 2013

Is Obamacare Crashing?

Since March 23, 2010 the country has been living in a constant psychotic state when it comes to reforming health care. While some have tried to implement the legislation and rules of the Affordable Care Act (Obamacare) others have religiously tried get rid of it altogether. Neither side has actually “won” as we have moved through the process but as a result we are now facing a health insurance market that doesn’t look anything like what those who supported the original legislation had hoped. It’s a mess.

Nobody should be surprised that there are going to need to be changes to what was originally written. The original legislation was much too complex, confusing, (and costly?) considering where the country was
positioned economically and politically. Unless the majority of Americans were on board, there is no way it was going to work.

The Treasury Department announced last week that they are pushing the employer requirement for providing health insurance (over 50 employees) until 2015. Additionally, the Department of Health and Human Services published rules that stated they were going to allow self-reporting of income information to determine insurance subsidies instead of verifying the information through the government.

Some believe this is the “beginning of the end” of Obamacare. (Republicans) Others view this as simply making the necessary changes to respond to the market realities. (Democrats/White House) Still others see these changes as the predictable outcome of creating something that was too big, too confusing, and too complex combined with poor implementation and terrible communication. (including me)

An opinion essay in the Wall Street Journal (Obamacare’s ‘Lair’ Subsidies; July 7, 2013) stated, “All of this fits with Obamacare’s entire bloody-minded history. Democrats were determined to make their rendeveous with the liberal destiny of government-run health care, so they imposed this debacle on the country on a partisan vote and despite public opposition.”

I don’t think it’s quite as bad as the Wall Street Journal describes it (and the position that Obamacare is “government-run” health care is a stretch) but  illustrates just how far apart the country continues to be when it comes to health care reform.

Many will continue to move forward to try to implement what was originally designed. Others will continue to oppose every aspect of the Affordable Care Act. At the same time, more changes to the original rules will likely occur and who knows what kind of health care system we’ll ultimately create- and at what cost?

In the meantime many individuals will have to continue to simply cope with the expensive and selective health system model we have today and try their best to understand the rules they are expected to follow. Citizens are going to need to be much more engaged in health care reform than they are today to break the political impasse. In the book Health Care Reform and American Politics; What Everyone Needs to Know, authors Lawrence Jacobs and Theda Skoopol summarize where we are; “We will continue to live in interesting times, where each citizen’s understanding, voice, and actions can make a difference.” 

Changes to the Affordable Care Act will continue to occur. The more individual citizens understand the basics of what is going on, the better the chances they will have to make a difference to influence the results.


Obamacare isn’t crashing, it’s just continuing to lose altitude due to economics and politics. Ultimately, it’s going to be up to the individual citizen to get health care reform on the right track again. As in the past, they will be forced to live with the results.  

Friday, June 21, 2013

Empowering Consumer Tribes In Health Care

We’ve been living with the Affordable Care Act for over three years now. The past three years were a perfect opportunity to educate the public about what health care reform actually is and the “value proposition” it provides. Most of the provisions of the ACA that will impact most Americans are just now coming up- and unfortunately, most of the American public has no clue. The value proposition and the roles of all the stakeholders in the new system were never clearly defined. We were too focused on fighting it rather than try to figure out the way to make sure it works.

“Consumer engagement” is another of the many buzzwords being thrown around in the new health care+

nomenclature. Engagement to health care is about getting people to do what health care wants them to do. In the current health care world, engagement is a transaction. Real engagement is about commitment and doing what is right.

Most of the general public agrees something needs to be done to fix the health care system in America. As we have been arguing for over 100 years the disagreement comes from how best to fix it.

 Consumer engagement is not just taking part in a transaction to participate in a wellness program because they are being paid or enrolling in the health insurance exchange to buy health insurance. Consumer engagement is about understanding that health care is now a social and economic issue in this country that needs to be addressed, and everyone needs to be on board to make it happen. Everyone.


With the lack of consumer trust in employers, government, and the health care system itself, individuals are looking for leadership to help guide them to do what they know needs to be done. In Seth Godin’s book, “Tribes,” he defines leadership as the ability to transform a “shared interest into a passionate goal and desire for change.” We have no leadership for the individual consumer in health care today. We simply have transaction managers. Transaction managers may do some things to get people to do what they want- but they won’t reach everyone that needs to be reached, and certainly won’t get individuals engaged.

Godin argues that good things happen when “tribes” have the leadership and shared vision to change the way things are. Crowds are simply tribes without a leader. Today, health care consumers are simply a large crowd seeking/begging for some leadership. When they get the leadership, many will become much more engaged than they are today.

Godin states, “The movement happens when people talk to one another, when ideas spread within the community, and most of all, when peer support leads people to do what they always knew was the right thing.”
Especially today, we need a consumer movement to begin in health care. Unfortunately, consumers are in dire need of a trusted leader they can rely on to share the vision, the goals, and the purpose of reforming our health care system- for everyone, not just a select few. When they have that leader, the movement will begin, and consumers will become engaged in the ways health care needs them to be engaged. They will change from a crowd to a tribe with a passionate vision for doing what is right.


The consumer leaders to create the engaged tribe won’t come from government, or employers, or health insurance companies. They will come from within the existing crowed- we just need to find them and provide the tools they need to do what they do best- facilitate the change that is needed.

Tuesday, April 23, 2013

Boston Marathon 2013- When Health Care Works

When we’re constantly reminded of all the things wrong with our health care system it’s pretty easy to be critical of it. We hear about all of the unnecessary costs, the inefficiencies, the errors, and the waste and we start to envision a system that can’t seem to do anything right. It’s easy to be negative about health care today.


While the health care system itself may be broken, there are times we need to remember those who are called to work in this broken system and perform their tasks admirably under difficult (or almost impossible) conditions.

We need to remember the medical teams at Massachusetts General, Bringham and Women’s Hospital, , Massachusetts General, Boston Children’s Hospital, and Beth Israel Deaconess Health Center who were called to respond to the tragedy at the Boston Marathon last week. We need to remember their hours of tireless effort as they worked together to save lives, save limbs, and treat the injuries of over 200 Americans. They didn’t care about insurance coverage or the patient’s ability to pay for the care they were receiving. They could have cared less about Obamacare or the fees they would receive for their work- these heroes were focused on doing what they were trained to do, to help save lives.

As we move back into the never-ending debate about how to fix the health care system let’s also take some time to recognize and appreciate when things work well. The Boston health care community responded admirably and continues to care for those recovering from a senseless act of violence (including the one who created it). Their compassion, dedication, and commitment will continue to guide their actions and help the victims heal. The first priority is care for the patient. That is the essence of what our health care system should be all about.

Wednesday, March 27, 2013

The ACA: More Expensive Than We Think

The Affordable Care Act has turned three and it’s been a rough three years.


The law has plowed through a number of legal challenges (and more will come), survived numerous attempts of repeal, and continues to face a largely unsupportive public. Nobody said changing health care would be easy. It just seems it could have been accomplished in a different way.

To be fair, during the three years since it passed the law has accomplished a few of the things it set out to do. But the real challenges are yet to come- and the challenges are all going to be about the cost.

When this whole effort began in 2010, the CBO estimated that even with the costs associated with it, the ACA would still reduce the debt by $147 billion over 10 years. I always keep in mind when Medicare and Medicaid were enacted in 1965 both program blew through their budget projections within the first two years. Government numbers seem to be optimistic and many times they are wrong. The CBO numbers are likely to be optimistic as well.

The Society of Actuaries released a study estimating that the “cost of claims” (and insurance) as a result of the provisions required in the ACA will increase costs (on average) by 32% in the individual market. The actual results vary by state with Ohio and Wisconsin the “winners” with their costs increasing over 80%. On the other hand, New York and Massachusetts insurance costs in the individual market would decrease by over 10%. On average, however, the costs nationwide will increase 32%.

Now, this 32% increase is only applicable to the individual health insurance market. However, health insurance companies have already indicated the costs on the employer side are likely to increase as well. We’ll know more when they start delivering their 2014 renewals to employers in a few months.

The ACA has focused way too much on getting more people into a costly, inefficient system. It does very little to address the real problem. Unfortunately, unless something dramatic changes we’re going to be paying for it- and it’s going to cost a lot. We’d better be prepared.



Wednesday, February 13, 2013

State of the Union- The Gridlock Will Continue


The President’s State of the Union address and Marco Rubio’s response underscored the fundamental challenge our country faces today.  We will continue to struggle with finding the right “balance” between free-market and government sponsored solutions to dig us out of the economic mess we find ourselves in. Unfortunately, the two messages couldn’t have been more different.

President Obama’s message was filled with government programs designed to stimulate economic growth. He clearly believes increased government spending can dig us out of hole we’re in. He stated, “Deficit reduction alone is not an economic plan.” This may be true- but the deficit can’t be ignored. The interest payments we’re paying on the debt is becoming a larger component of the federal budget. If interest rates start to rise (and they will eventually) we could find ourselves in a bind that will be tough to get out. His overall package sounded very expensive.
Rubio countered with a smaller government and a deficit-reduction message.  He (and his colleagues) believe the increased spending and increased taxes will actually backfire and hurt the middle class. Unfortunately, he didn’t provide a lot of specifics on the programs he would recommend.

It was interesting to note that both Obama and Rubio agree on the primary issues facing the country- the economy, jobs, health care, and education. Their methods for addressing them are polar opposite and (as has been said many times before) the real answer is somewhere between the two.

Unfortunately, with the political picture we face today we are unlikely to come to some common-ground; and the gridlock concerning the economy (and health care) will continue while the debt and deficit will continue to grow. The State of the Union messages only reinforced this fact.

Tuesday, January 1, 2013

The Health Care Fiscal Cliff is Next

No matter where your political views lie- most will agree that President Obama is a really good communicator. He’s easy to listen to, what he says seems to sound logical, and he just comes across as a “nice guy.” But, like everything else on the political scene anymore, I just don’t know if I trust him.


Obama gave another “photo op” speech yesterday to try to get the general public more engaged in the fiscal cliff debate in Congress. In front on an obviously staged audience, and standing in front of 14 “average Americans,” the President encouraged those watching to keep the pressure on Congress to get a deal done to avert the economic collision they created. Once again, his comments sounded logical, he was easy to listen to, and he seemed like a nice guy.

But he made a comment during his remarks that took me by surprise- and it was about Medicare.

Ever since March, 2010 I’ve been trying to get behind the health care model that was created by the Affordable Care Act. I don’t like the law, I don’t agree with many aspects of the law, but it is the law. Something has to be done to fix the crisis we’re going to experience with health care costs and the Affordable Care Act is what we have to work with. There are some provisions in the law that makes sense and a lot of things that don’t. But I thought it was all supposed to be based on changing the trajectory of health care costs (including Medicare) and contribute to a reduction in our deficit over time.

Yesterday, to highlight his willingness to compromise on a fiscal cliff deal, President Obama said, “For example, I’m willing to reduce our government’s Medicare bills by finding new ways to reduce the cost of health care in this country. . . We want to make sure that Medicare is there for future generations. But the current trajectory of health care costs has gone up so high, we’ve got to find ways to make sure that it’s sustainable.”

Silly me, I thought that was the whole idea behind the Affordable Care Act.

With the exception of enrolling more people into a high-cost, inefficient, health care system- I’m not sure what the Affordable Care Act is about any more. All I know is that it’s going to be expensive and it’s going to get even more complicated; not what I thought I was signing-up for.

Happy New Year

Friday, November 30, 2012

Asking the Wrong Questions


For the first time since 2000, Gallup has found a majority of Americans now feel it is not the federal government’s responsibility to make sure all Americans have healthcare coverage. According to a recent poll, 54% now feel it is not the government’s responsibility as opposed to 44% who say it is. 

Gallup also found most of those interviewed still think health care system has some major problems, don’t like the costs, but are generally satisfied with the care received when needed.

Whether or not it is the federal government’s responsibility to make sure American’s have health insurance isn’t the real question. If the question was changed to, “Is it the responsibility of the federal government to make sure American’s have access to affordable health care?” the answer results might be different. Considering the fact that health care costs are now impacting the entire economy, I know I’d say it is.

It’s pretty amazing that after all that has happened we’re still having separate discussions around these topics and haven’t put them together. Health insurance financing of health care and an affordable health care system are related.

The Health Care system is moving in the right direction but is resisting the change any way it can. It’s going slow. Until we bring the general public on-board, making the changes that are going to be required is going to be much more difficult. If we used Gallup’s numbers and assume over half the country may be resist the changes that are coming because they don’t understand them, the challenge may be overwhelming.

That is why educating the public about what is going on and getting them engaged critical. They are going to need to be more engaged than they are today to make the change happen.

Friday, November 16, 2012

Now Fix the Affordable Care Act

The election is over. It was close, but not as close as some thought it might be. At least we now have an idea of the direction we’re heading as we try to fix health care. The Affordable Care Act (ACA) is certainly not perfect and not too many folks actually like it (it’s expensive and very few understand how the pieces of the law are all supposed to fit together). But it’s what we have to work with.


The House of Representatives continues to be controlled by the Republicans and the Senate by the Democrats. And we have a Democratic President. No change from where we were before. The respective numbers changed slightly in both the House and Senate, but the overall picture looks the same. Hopefully, the two sides will start working better together more than they have been the last four years.

The pundits are analyzing the results. Some think President Obama has a “mandate” from the general population. I don’t think so. He was simply given more time to deliver results. This wasn’t a mandate, it was a message. Most of the general public is exhausted from the process and simply wants Washington to start fixing what needs to be fixed and quit the political warfare that has already cost us our debt rating has brought us close to the “fiscal cliff” that will occur on January 1 if some pretty bold actions aren’t taken, and the debt and costs continue to grow and the average citizen continues to feel the results. We won’t fix our problems if the two sides don’t start working better together. President Obama needs to lead by example.

Now would be a good time for both sides to sit down and re-evaluate the intent and status of the Affordable Care Act implementation. They should get rid of the costs and unnecessary bureaucracy that may not make sense considering our current economic picture. Some of the ideas that might have seemed logical in 2009-2010 may not be all that logical today.

The Affordable Care Act has some good ideas but in many ways misses the point on the fundamental problem we need to address. The ACA focusses on access (getting everyone into the health insurance pool; mandating health insurance) and doesn’t really deal with the costs until we’re further down the road. Cost is the issue. Including more people in a system that doesn’t immediately address the costs of health care is going to make the Affordable Care Act much more expensive than anticipated- ultimately losing any support from the general public it might have had.

Consumers/individuals will need to get on board at some point if the Affordable Care Act is going to work. Those in Washington can set the tone by doing what is right and doing what makes sense for us today.

Both sides need to have open minds. Instead of barreling “full steam ahead” regardless of the costs just to meet deadlines, DHHS (Department of Health and Human Services) should step back and (as a good Top Gun quote goes) “evaluate what has happened so you can apply what you’ve learned.”

Washington needs to work together to fix what needs fixing.

That’s what we elected them to do.

Sunday, November 4, 2012

Election 2012- We've Only Just Begun

The election is Tuesday. Most are going to be glad when it’s finally over. But it’s really not going to be over- no matter who wins. It’s only the beginning.


We have some serious issues to address in this country. We can continue to kick the can down the road like we’ve been doing but we’re running out of road. And the stakes just keep getting bigger. We’re sitting here like the proverbial frog in the slowly boiling pot. We feel things getting hot, but we are not able to ask for a helping hand to get us out. Our politics won’t allow it.

It’s very likely that deciding the Presidential election on Tuesday may be a drawn-out affair. It is going to be close and could result in a president who has won the electoral college not the popular vote. That is not necessarily unusual. George W. Bush, Harry Truman, Woodrow Wilson (both times), Grover Cleveland (both times), Rutherford Hayes, Thomas Jefferson, and others have experienced the same thing. But this one may be different. Boatloads of lawyers are standing at the ready to challenge any and all aspects of the results. It could pull the country further apart rather than pulling us together.

At this point, it looks like the House will continue to be controlled by the Republicans and the Senate controlled by the Democrats. This hasn’t worked out all that well over the past four years. The emotions, the events, and the politics have created the most partisan Congress we’ve ever experienced in this country.

While the political process becomes more polarized we look ahead to “fiscal cliff” and the suffocating costs of health care we still have to address. Addressing them the right way will require real teamwork and collaboration between the parties and their constituents to reach some consensus on how to move forward. That’s the way a democracy is supposed to work. If we decide to keep growing further apart, every American is going to feel the consequences in some way or another.

So, no matter who ultimately “wins” the presidency on Tuesday (or whenever it is finally decided) this is only the beginning for the rest of us. Just because the election is settled doesn’t mean we can all shut-off our minds and move on to other things. There is too much at stake. We have a role we need to play to continue to hold those we have elected accountable and setting a direction that is good for the country and not based solely on a single political ideology. Believe it or not, both sides have some good ideas to share. Neither one has a lock on being right. While the elections may set a direction, we (the citizens) can do a lot to set the tone and demand the results.

We have a choice- not only about who is leading our country but about how it is going to be led. Now more than ever we need to stay involved and stay engaged and remain an integral part of the political process. If we continue to let individual party-ideology reign as the key determinant of how we're going to work in America- we're all going to lose. The choice is ours.

Thursday, October 4, 2012

Romney Won The Debate- But Still Not Clear About Health Care

There’s no doubt about it- from a political scorecard point of view, Mitt Romney “won” the debate last night. He was clear in his remarks and came across as the executive you would expect him to be; a very solid performance. President Obama didn’t seem like he just wasn’t into it and would rather be somewhere else. He didn’t go on the attack like his more liberal followers expected. Chris Mathews and Ed Schultz (MSNBC) went into a tirade after the debate lamenting the fact that Obama missed an opportunity to put Romney away. Today, Rush Limbaugh and Shawn Hannity are declaring victory and triumph for the other side.


While the pundits may have expected more fireworks (particularly from Obama) I actually enjoyed the debate. I know I’m in the minority but I like it when a debate includes a factual discussion of the issues that are relevant to those watching it.

Jim Leher (the moderator) had his critics as well. Once again, I didn’t think he did that bad. I enjoyed the free flow of the discussion as opposed to the game-show atmosphere that was prevalent in some of the debates we watched during the Republican primary. Once again, in today’s world my view is certainly the minority. Our culture today seems to want the fireworks, the vitriol, and the entertainment as opposed to a no-nonsense factual debate of the issues to educate the general public.

While Romney performed well when addressing the topic areas (the debt, the economy, taxes) he still didn’t address the question of how he was proposing to fix health care. He talked about RomneyCare and premium support for Medicare but didn't address how it was all supposed to work. The facts he used to summarize his position were generally misleading, lacked context, and he didn’t provide the specifics needed for the average citizen to make an informed decision about the best approach to use to fix the crisis we’re in.

For me, it’s pretty simple: Addressing the unsustainable increasing costs of health care is one of the most critical issues facing our country today. If we fix health care, we can go a long way to addressing our debt. If we address our debt we can go further in growing the economy. If we grow the economy we can create jobs. And that’s the issue for many.

Obamacare (the Affordable Care Act) is too expensive and doesn’t go nearly as far as we need to go to change how health care delivery works in this country. Obamacare needs to be fixed but it’s a start. In my view, Mitt Romney and Paul Ryan still need to present a plan (not just talking points but an actual plan) that makes sense as an alternative to the Affordable Care Act- then, voters like me (who believe health care may very well create the next economic crisis in our country if something doesn’t change) can make a clear decision on which approach is best.

And that will determine the way we vote.

Tuesday, September 11, 2012

9-11; Eleven Years Later




Let us never forget

And always remember those who have sacrificed and continue to sacrifice to fight for our freedom.